There is a name that few pilgrims pronounce as they cross the arid hills east of Ramallah, and yet, since August 9, 2026, this name has carried the weight of a reality that no commentator would have dared to prophesy. Taybeh, the last entirely Christian village in the West Bank, has been declared a "closed military zone" by the Israeli army, officially to protect it from increasing settler attacks. But this Arabic name, meaning "the good one," conceals another, older, more somber one: Ephraim. It is there, in this small town now enclosed by metal barriers and surrounded by settlements, that the Gospel places Jesus' final retreat before his Passion, when "the chief priests and the Pharisees" had decided to put him to death: "He withdrew to the nearby region of the desert, to a town called Ephraim, and there he stayed with his disciples" (John 11:54).
This verse, long read as a mere topographical detail in the story of Lazarus's resurrection, takes on a resonance in the summer of 2026 that transcends scholarly exegesis. The place where the Son of God hid to escape his impending death has once again become, two thousand years later, a place of hiding, a place where people wait for the violence to pass, a place where, each morning, they wonder if the Christian presence will survive the next generation. Local church leaders, from the parish priest to the Patriarch of Jerusalem, no longer conceal their anxiety: what is at stake in Taybeh is not simply a matter of military security, but the very possibility that, in a few decades, the last entirely Christian community on Earth, the birthplace of Christianity, will disappear.
A city under seal, a dwindling population
On August 9, 2026, the head of the Israeli army's Central Command signed an order declaring Taybeh, along with the neighboring village of Rammun, a "closed military zone." The measure, presented as a shield to prevent Israelis and settlers from entering the area after a series of attacks—including the August 5 raid on an empty family home—theoretically prohibits access to the village for Israeli citizens and foreigners, but leaves Palestinian residents free to move about. Father Bachar Fawadleh, parish priest of the Latin Church of Christ the Redeemer, initially greeted the decision with cautious optimism: "The declaration of Taybeh as a closed military zone for non-Israeli residents can be a positive step if it is actually and consistently enforced to prevent settlers from entering our land and committing further attacks.".
But the poorly explained order has sown more confusion than reassurance. It bars entry to Israelis and foreigners with no direct connection to the village, while leaving the army itself vague about the concrete methods of implementation and control. On the ground, journalists attempting to reach the village take nearly an hour to travel the twelve kilometers separating Taybeh from Ramallah, due to the military checkpoints scattered along the road. A metal gate installed by the army, opened or closed without warning, now obstructs daily traffic to the surrounding major Palestinian cities. The so-called closed zone thus not only protects against settler intrusion: it also isolates the village, restricting residents' access to their own olive groves, farmland, and livelihoods.
This administrative strangulation is hitting an already depleted community hard. Taybeh had around three thousand inhabitants in the 1980s; today, it has only between eleven hundred and twelve hundred, according to the most recent estimates from local churches. Since the start of the war in Gaza in October 2023, at least fifteen to sixteen families have left the village, meaning about seventy people have been uprooted from their ancestral land. Nadim Khoury, founder of the first brewery in Palestine, located in Taybeh, sums up the downward spiral with clear-eyed bitterness: "Fifteen families have already left since October 23rd, because there is no longer any future for them." Reverend Mitri Raheb, founder of Dar al-Kalima University in Bethlehem, goes even further in his warning: if current conditions persist, he cautions, there will not be a single Christian left in the West Bank by 2050. More than two hundred Christian families have already left the occupied territory since 2023.
What Taybeh's hidden name reveals
We must momentarily suspend geopolitical analysis here to return to what sacred geography teaches us. Pilgrims of antiquity, as early as the Bordeaux itinerary written in 333 AD, already identified Ephraim with present-day Taybeh, some twenty kilometers northeast of Jerusalem, on the edge of the Judean Desert. Franciscan excavations carried out on the site have unearthed first-century domestic pottery, wine presses, and ritual stone vessels, confirming the existence of a flourishing Jewish community at the very time when Jesus withdrew there. This is therefore not a minor biblical coincidence: it is a real, dated, excavated place that the Gospel of John designates as the final refuge before the entry into Jerusalem and the Passion.
The context of this withdrawal deserves careful consideration. Just before, in the eleventh chapter of the Gospel of John, the high priest Caiaphas had uttered this terrible and unintentionally prophetic statement before the Sanhedrin: «It is better for you that one man die for the people than that the whole nation perish» (John 11:50). It was following this plot against his life that Jesus «stopped walking about publicly among the Jews» and went to Ephraim. The withdrawal, therefore, was not a fearful flight, but a strategic waiting, a suspended time before the hour set by the Father. The evangelist specifies, with a restraint that hints at the intensity of the moment: «He stayed there with his disciples» (John 11:54). This stay in Ephraim was a time of close community, of fraternity lived in uncertainty, just a few kilometers from the city where his death was being plotted.
But this is precisely what the inhabitants of Taybeh are experiencing today: a suspended time, a community drawn inward, a fraternity tested by the constant proximity of danger. The Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem, Cardinal Pierbattista Pizzaballa, could not ignore this resonance when he traveled to Taybeh on Saturday, August 15, 2026, for the Feast of the Assumption, and celebrated Mass in the Latin Church of Christ the Redeemer. Before the assembled faithful, he spoke words that bear the mark of this profound biblical awareness: «We will continue to do everything in our power to preserve the presence of the Church here, at every level, throughout the Holy Land. I may not have answers on a human or worldly level, but I believe in God. And I am certain that in Him, we can continue to bear life, even here in Taybeh.» Then, addressing the community directly: "Be brave, do not be afraid.".
What the patriarch is affirming here, without explicitly naming it, is precisely the logic of the retreat to Ephraim: remaining in the place of danger without giving in to panic, inhabiting uncertainty without renouncing hope. «We want to continue to be a life-giving community, without renouncing or abandoning our rights, our right to life,» he added, specifying that the power of evil is not absolute. These words are not mere formulas of pastoral comfort: they are part of the theological continuity of a place that, two millennia earlier, had already been the refuge of the Word made flesh in the face of the threat of death.
The Church in the Holy Land: A Voice That Rises to the Top
The concern expressed in Taybeh did not remain confined to the local level. As early as July 2025, Greek Orthodox Patriarch Theophilos III and Cardinal Pizzaballa issued a joint statement accusing Israeli authorities of facilitating, through their inaction, the presence of extremists around the village. The Council of Patriarchs and Church Leaders of Jerusalem called for "an immediate and transparent investigation" into the lack of police response to the community's emergency appeals, denouncing a "growing trend of systematic and targeted attacks" constituting "a direct and intentional threat" against the historical and religious heritage of their ancestors and holy sites. Cardinal Pizzaballa summarized the situation in a sentence that remains strikingly relevant a year later: "Throughout the West Bank, and not only here, the only law that prevails today is the law of might, of those who have power, not right.".
That same year, a detailed dossier documenting settler attacks was submitted to Pope Leo XIV for review, demonstrating that the Taybeh issue had already reached the highest levels of the Holy See even before the 2026 military closure. French President Emmanuel Macron also directly addressed the situation with the Latin Patriarch, expressing "France's solidarity with all Palestinian Christians, from Gaza to Taybeh, who are currently under threat." In June 2026, during a visit to France, Cardinal Pizzaballa reiterated his concern, denouncing a situation where "spirituality is being confiscated" in the Holy Land.
Pope Leo XIV himself has consistently mentioned the West Bank and Gaza in his Sunday addresses since his election. On July 26, 2026, following the Angelus prayer recited at Castel Gandolfo, he stated that he was following "with apprehension the persistence and escalation of violence in the Holy Land," explicitly naming the territories in question. Three weeks later, on August 16—two days after the Mass celebrated by Pizzaballa in Taybeh—the pontiff reiterated his appeal, declaring: "I renew my call to end the repeated violence against the Palestinian civilian population in the West Bank" and urging "the international community to act in order to advance the two-state solution, for a just and lasting peace." This repeated insistence, week after week, on a specific territory and on a named population, reflects a concern that goes beyond the usual diplomatic rhetoric of the Holy See: it is the attention paid to a concrete flock, which the supreme pastor knows could, for lack of protection, disappear from the spiritual map of the Holy Land.
The temptation of exile and loyalty despite everything
Father Fawadleh, the parish priest of Taybeh, tries every day to reassure the 1,150 inhabitants who still remain in the village and to prevent their departure. This pastoral task takes on the appearance of a patient, almost silent, resistance struggle waged against demographic decline as much as against physical violence. For what threatens Taybeh is not only the brutal and visible attack—the burning of a house, the settlers' livestock released onto the olive groves, the sign planted by radicals announcing that "there is no future for you here"—but also the slow erosion, the economic calculation, the question that each family asks itself night after night: does staying still make sense?
Without access to their olive groves, without the possibility of moving freely within the region, many residents have already chosen to leave. The agricultural area of Taybeh covers 2,400 hectares, 1,500 of which fall under Area C, the zone where the Israeli civil and military administration exercises total control over the land—an area that the most radical wing of the Israeli government is openly working to annex, as it has done with 60 percent of the West Bank. This administrative reality, invisible to the world, weighs far more heavily on the village's future than the spectacular images of sporadic clashes.
In interviews given over the past few months, the priest of Taybeh alternates between a clear-eyed assessment of the gravity of the situation and a call for spiritual steadfastness. He himself has acknowledged that many in his community are seriously considering emigration, and he has not hesitated to directly appeal to the international community, particularly the United States, asking them to put pressure on Israel "if they want Palestinian Christians to remain." This request, made with the simplicity of a pastor watching his flock dwindle, resonates like a belated echo of the supplication of the prophet Jeremiah, himself a powerless witness to the dispersion of his people: "Woe to me! For the Lord has added sorrow upon sorrow. All my labor is in vain; my tent is destroyed, and all my cords are broken" (Jeremiah 10:19-20). The image of the torn tent, of broken ropes, says with an almost unbearable accuracy what families who, after centuries of continuous presence in Taybeh, are considering leaving are experiencing: it is not just a house that is being left, it is an entire fabric of memory, of liturgy, of fidelity passed down from generation to generation, that is being torn apart.
And yet, at the very heart of this wear and tear, another message persists, woven into the First Epistle of Peter, addressed to the scattered and afflicted Christians of Asia Minor: «You yourselves, like living stones, are being built into a spiritual house to be a holy priesthood, offering spiritual sacrifices acceptable to God through Jesus Christ» (1 Peter 2:5). This image of the living stone, embedded in a structure larger than itself, sheds a particular light on what each family remaining in Taybeh represents: it is not alone in bearing the weight of the Christian presence in the Holy Land; it participates in a much older and much larger edifice, that of a local Church which, since apostolic times, has never completely disappeared from this land, despite the Crusades, the Ottoman and British empires, and successive wars.
A presence that endures like a cornerstone
What Taybeh embodies today, beyond the immediate crisis of the closed military zone, is the question of whether the Christian presence in the Holy Land is still a living vocation or a survival on borrowed time. Local religious leaders no longer hide the fact that the scenario of total disappearance, evoked by Reverend Raheb for the year 2050, is no longer a theoretical hypothesis but a statistical trajectory observable, year after year, in the parish registers. The Latin Patriarchate of Jerusalem, aware of this urgency, is increasing its pastoral visits—those of June 2024, summer 2025, and August 15, 2026—in a visible effort to maintain a tangible link between the Church and a community that might feel abandoned.
Cardinal Jean-Marc Aveline, who came on a solidarity pilgrimage in August 2025 with the blessing of Pope Leo XIV, also celebrated Mass in Taybeh alongside the three parish priests of the village's Christian communities. This gesture was intended to remind everyone that the universal Church does not consider this community a mere declining statistic, but a living member of the entire ecclesiastical body. This type of visit, repeated by various figures in the Catholic Church, reflects an implicit strategy: to counter the psychological and spiritual isolation that, even more than physical violence, drives families into exile. For a Christian who feels forgotten by the world is more likely to succumb to the temptation to leave than one who knows that Rome, Marseille, or Jerusalem remember his name and his village.
In this insistence by the highest authorities of the Church on naming Taybeh, there is an implicit theology of the Incarnation that deserves to be emphasized. Christianity is not a religion of disembodied ideas: it is rooted in specific places, specific stones, specific faces. That Christ chose Ephraim—the village now identified with Taybeh—as the place of his final rest before the Passion is not an anecdotal detail of Gospel geography: it is a sign that God dwells in the concrete places of human fragility, in border areas, in threatened villages, in communities with dwindling numbers. The prophet Zephaniah, in a rarely quoted but strikingly relevant oracle for the present situation, already announced that the Lord would gather a faithful "remnant" from among the scattered nations: "I will leave in your midst a humble and few people, who will take refuge in the name of the Lord" (Zephaniah 3:12). This "remnant"—she'erit in biblical Hebrew—is not a notion of defeat, but a promise of hidden fruitfulness: the small number does not invalidate the mission, it concentrates it.
Taybeh, with its eleven or twelve hundred inhabitants, embodies today, in a very concrete way, the remnant of which Zephaniah speaks. Its small population is not necessarily a sign of programmed extinction, but perhaps, in the biblical logic of the faithful remnant, the very place where a fruitfulness is being prepared that demographic statistics cannot measure. It is this conviction, more than any geopolitical calculation, that seems to motivate Cardinal Pizzaballa when he affirms that "the power of evil is not absolute" and invites the inhabitants to remain "a life-giving community.".
But this theological hope does not preclude a clear-eyed view of the concrete material conditions that make this fidelity possible or impossible. Without secure access to farmland, without economic prospects for younger generations, without guarantees of free movement between the village and surrounding urban centers, the theology of the small remnant risks becoming a discourse of consolation disconnected from the reality experienced by families hesitating between staying and leaving. This is why the repeated appeals of Pope Leo XIV to the international community, as well as the requests for investigation made by the patriarchs of Jerusalem, are not simply matters of ecclesiastical diplomacy: they constitute the other, necessarily political and legal, side of the spiritual fidelity called to be embodied in Taybeh.
📁 Special Report
Leo XIV1300 articles
Leo XIV, the first American pope, facing AI and digital technology: profile, social legacy of Leo XIII and challenges…
Access the folder →The future of this village, where the Gospel places Christ's last refuge before Jerusalem, will therefore depend on this twofold vigilance: that of hearts that refuse to yield to fear, and that of international bodies called upon to finally ensure that law prevails over force. The whole world is looking, often unknowingly, toward this small town in the arid hills where, two thousand years ago, the Son of Man chose to dwell for a time with his disciples before facing his Passion—and where, even today, very real disciples remain, in uncertainty, refusing to leave the land where their faith was born.
Lectio divina
«He withdrew to the region near the desert, to a town called Ephraim, and he stayed there with his disciples.» John 11:54
You know that moment when staying becomes a heavier choice than leaving. Christ, threatened with death, didn't flee far away: he withdrew close by, to a fragile place, with his followers. What would you do if remaining faithful to your land required living every day under threat? Are you one of those who stay because they still believe that presence has meaning, even if they are a minority, even if threatened?
Lord, you who chose Ephraim to hide yourself in for a time, look upon Taybeh today. You know the weight of the olive trees that can no longer be reached, the houses one hesitates to leave, the children one longs to protect. Stay with those who remain. Give them your silent courage, the courage that crossed the desert without flinching. Make their few number a living stone in your building. Do not abandon them to fear.
An oil lamp still flickers in the night of a village surrounded by silent hills.
✝ Biblical references
4 passages · 4 books
Cast all your anxieties on him, for you are precious in his eyes. (1 Peter 5:7)
Encouragement to persecuted Christians: hope, baptism and conduct in society.
→ Explore Codex 1 Stone- Leo XIV and the gesture of Saint Ignatius of Antioch: when Rome learned to sing with one voice with the East
- Norway 2030: When a king killed by the sword becomes the seed of a Church
- These Russian Catholics whom Rome calls upon to become living bridges
- When American charity meets the memory of Hippo: Leo XIV's words to the Vincentians
God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son. (John 3:16)
The Gospel of the Word: a profound theology of the Incarnation and the signs of Jesus.
→ Explore the Codex John- This is truly an Israelite: there is no deceit in him. (John 1:45-51)
- Dry bones, hear the word of the Lord: from your graves I will raise you up, O my people (Ezekiel 37:1-14)
- If anyone serves me, my Father will honor him (John 12:24-26)
- Herod sent and beheaded John in prison. John's disciples went and told Jesus (Mt 14:1-12)
- In order to gather into one the scattered children of God (Jn 11:45-57)
- When God refuses to justify himself: the sign of Jonah and the faith that sees
- «"Let it be done according to your faith" — John Cassian and the mystery of faith that opens heaven
- The God of the Living: When Eternity Tears the Veil of Time
- The joy that remains: when Jesus fulfills man's deepest desire
- When cynicism becomes prophecy: the death of Jesus and the gathering of God's children
- Ephraim under siege: what Leo XIV said when he named the West Bank
- Taybeh under seal: when the last Christian city in the Holy Land becomes an open-air prison
- Taybeh, besieged Ephraim: the cry of a village thought to have already left
- When the Pope speaks, the bombs keep falling: Leo XIV, prophet of peace between two wars
I will make a new covenant with the house of Israel. (Jeremiah 31:31)
Prophet of the destruction of Jerusalem and of the new covenant of the heart.
→ Explore the Codex Jeremiah
The Lord your God is in your midst, a mighty warrior who saves. (Zephaniah 3:17)
Announcement of the Day of the Lord and oracle of joy for the humble remnant of Israel.
→ Explore the Codex Sophonia- Leo XIV at the nunciature in Buenos Aires: when the Church chose discretion to prepare for the immense
- When Westminster speaks of Taybeh: the English Church confronts the silence of nations
- In Moscow, unarmed peace finally has a Russian face
- Becoming bridges in Asia: Synodality as missionary conversion
🌍 1 Catholic country
Today, Israel is home to a Catholic community of approximately 2% of the population, present in some of Christianity's holiest sites. The Christian presence in the Holy Land dates back to the 1st century, from life and death to…
Discover Israel →
